Case Studies

Urban Financial Inclusion in India – A Case Study of Dharavi Mumbai

Dharavi in Mumbai, India is the largest slum colony in Asia. Most of Dharavi residents are migrants either working in factories and eateries or involved in self employed activities. Initially, officials of ‘Indian bank ‘and volunteers contacted the residents of Dharavi at their residence and encouraged them to open bank accounts under simplified KYC norms as part of it’s urban financial inclusion initiative.

dharavi india case study

Dharavi Slums of India. Img-credit:wikimedia.org

Urban Financial Inclusion in India

The services of volunteers, community leaders and NGO’s started producing encouraging results in a short time. Enthused by the positive response and after assessing the potential, Indian bank decided to open a branch in Dharavi in February, 2007.

Today this branch is supported by three ATMs, two on site and one offsite. The bank has also achieved a business of Rs 60 crores with more than 30,000 ‘no-frill accounts”. The bank has tested the potential of the huge commercial benefits. Encouraged with the success, the same bank is planning to open one more branch supported by more ATMs in Dharavi.

The analysis of the Dharavi experiment reveals a few interesting facts:

  • Initial capital outlay on one branch and three ATMs should have been not more than Rs 40 lakhs (Rs. 20 lakhs for branch and Rs 6.5 lakhs for each ATM).
  • An account becomes commercially viable if average balance in accounts is Rs 5000/-.
  • The bank must have recovered it’s one time cost in first two years itself.

This example is sufficient to give an idea about the potential of urban financial exclusion. The need is to take the first mover advantage and to move to thickly populated areas which are a little far off from heart of the chosen urban centre. The Dharavi Banking experiment has shown that people perceived as poor are not so poor and they are rich enough and should be considered as bankable.

At present, more than 85 million households in India do not have access to formal banking channels. Out of these, 40 percent are in urban India. In absolute numbers, 34 millions households are financially excluded in urban India. If we presume that every year 2% of the rural financially excluded households will migrate to urban centers then the urban figure gets inflated by 1 million (10 lakhs) in one year and 5 million (50 lakhs) households in five years.

Dharavi Case Study

Another related case study is that of FINO-Tatkaal: Financial inclusion for migrants of Dharavi

Banking scenario in India with special reference to Urban India

Banking presence in urban India is diverse and varied. The larger the city, the larger is the variety of financial products and services available. Till now foreign banks have by and large restricted their presence to select cities focusing primarily on big corporate houses.

The foreign banks have favored cities such as Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata, Chennai, Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Pune, Noida, Gurgaon, Chandigarh etc. The concentration of private sector banks is primarily restricted to top 36 cities with a million plus population.

Public sector banks and the State bank of India have managed to reach the block level with the exception of 99 blocks out of which 86 blocks are in north eastern parts of India and are sparsely populated and hence economically unviable. These are further supported by urban cooperative banks, district central cooperative banks, NBFC’s , MFI’s and SHG’s in urban areas.

Recent developments in technology have transformed banking from the traditional brick and mortar infrastructure to a system supplemented by other channels like automated teller machines (ATM), credit/debit cards, internet banking, online money transfer, mobile banking etc.

Initially this technology was available to a chosen few but slowly the technology outreach is fast spreading to everyone covered under formal financing channels. Technology is helping in a big way by reducing distances.

On the flip side, regional rural banks formally introduced in 1975 with a focus on rural areas have failed to grow at the desired speed due to a number of factors. On the other hand Urban Co-operative Banks ( UCB’s) have also failed to grow except in select geographical pockets (especially Maharashtra) of India. Wherever UCB’s are successful even at those places, they could not bring financially left out into the fold of formal banking channels.

The process of globalization and integration of India’s external trade with the rest of the world has strengthened the Indian economy. Today Indian banks are making foreign forays/ For banks, time is right to re-set the urban agenda in view of vibrancy in economy.

Under JNNURM, the main focus will be on roads,water supply,sewage system, solid waste management, transportation, rain water drainage. Power and housing being other two focused societal needs. ‘India infrastructure Development Fund’ is likely to take shape soon resulting into more employment opportunities.

It’s time for Banks to rethink the urban agenda.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top